Saturday, 14 February 2015

Shared Storytelling is a Battle Royale

Everything that I know about running a LARP, I learned from pro-wrestling.

I know I've written the above line on this blog before (entry here), but I did say that I would re-visit the similarities between pro-wrestling and live-action role-play.  Previously, I was writing about endings and the effects of "hot" or "clean" finishes.  Today, I read an article - "How to become a better Larper" - that Elle had posted on G+, and I was reminded again of the overlap between the skills that LARPs require, and the skills that wrestlers develop.

From watching wrestling and reading about it, I've learned that the skills that contribute to a successful wrestling show are the same ones that make a LARP game enjoyable for all of the players.  Similarly, the behaviour that is most destructive to the long-term prospects of a live-action chronicle is just as poisonous in a wrestling promotion.  Elle's review of the above article said something that applies equally to LARP and wrestling: "We create shared stories, emphasis on shared.  It's not all about you and your character.  The best games are those where everyone works together to make the most awesome story they can manage."

Wrestling is, of course, a form of storytelling in which some of the participants are very experienced and have well-established characters, while others are new to the business and trying to catch a break.  A promotion's success depends on it having a number of characters and plot lines that have "gotten over" with the fans.  "Getting over" is a common term that people in the wrestling business use to describe success, but they don't always mean popularity.  For a heel, success is being booed and widely despised.  The important thing is to elicit a strong reaction, which is described as "heat".

Of course, some wrestlers are only concerned with their own success, but the most respected are the ones that understand the need to share the limelight and not put themselves before the story.

Perhaps the most powerful lesson in the history of wrestling comes from the fall of WCW - a wrestling promotion that Ted Turner once owned.  With his backing in the 1990s, WCW became big enough to rival Vince MacMahon's WWE, which had for years been the biggest wrestling company in the world.  However, WCW threw away all of its money and success.  Part of its downfall can be attributed to wrestlers behaving in ways that you might expect from problem players in a long-term LARP.

A major problem was that a clique of wrestlers - including Hulk Hogan - were making story decisions behind the scenes.  Hogan may be a wildly popular wrestler among fans, but he made his reputation in the days when the industry was refusing to acknowledge publicly that wrestling is staged.  Behind the scenes, he has for a long time had a reputation of not knowing how to promote anyone but himself.  When he and a group of well-established and like-minded wrestlers had influence over the booking in WCW, they hogged the limelight.  This caused WCW shows to become boring and predictable; week after week, Hogan and his group - the nWo - would always triumph.  Backstage, the most influential group of wrestlers were acting like they were a class above the others.  In an interview about WCW, AJ Styles - who was a rookie when he worked there - said that if guys like Hogan, Kevin Nash or Scott Steiner were arguing about plot in the locker room, then it was time for everyone not in the clique to leave and go somewhere else.  This soon became not just an arrogant way to treat less-experienced wrestlers, but also an arrogant way to treat the fans.

The nadir came with "the finger poke of death".  A great main event match between Hogan and Nash for the world title was promised, but the plot twist was that Nash was in league with Hogan.  Hogan poked him in the chest, and Nash lay down to be pinned and ceded the world championship.  The fans were outraged; sure - wrestling's fake, but the customers nonetheless expect to see an entertaining staged fight.  This kind of treatment, combined with a few other terrible business decisions, caused WCW's fan base to start hemorrhaging supporters, eventually leading to the promotion's collapse.  By the time that Vince MacMahon purchased WCW as a way of dismantling it, it was worth so little that Chris Jericho once said that, if he had known at the time how little it sold for, he would have put in a competing bid.

As you can tell, I've listened to a few commentaries from current and former wrestlers about the rise and fall of WCW.  Shane Douglas, whom I mentioned in my last post about wrestling, once remarked "That's why you should never let the lunatics run the asylum."

I think that this is something that Larpers should give some thought: an entire multi-million dollar company that was built on storytelling collapsed, and part of the cause was people playing in cliques, plots being decided among people that had a conflict of interests, and wrestlers refusing to share the limelight with others.

Personally, if I want a story about someone learning to share, I think about a wrestler called Rhyno.  When Rhyno (real name Terry Gerin) finished his training in Detroit, he asked whom he was first going to beat in the ring.  Seeing that he still had a lot to learn about shared story-telling, his coach and promoter Scott D'Amore said that he would make calls and get Rhyno into any wrestling show or promotion that he could arrange - provided that Rhyno lost every single match for the first year of his career.  Partly, this was about Rhyno getting some humility and "paying his dues" - almost all of the wrestlers in the industry have to spend the early part of their careers taking losses while they learn the ropes.  However, the other part was about teaching Rhyno to participate in a story without having to "win" it.

Some of the most respected wrestlers are the ones that have learned to make stories interesting without needing those stories to end in their favour, and some Larpers could learn a valuable lesson from their examples.  For instance, in his autobiography A Lion's Tale, Chris Jericho describes an occasion when he was playing a heel and scheduled to lose to Goldberg - a popular face.  Goldberg was winning a lot of "squash matches" - that's a term for a quick one-sided fight that serves to show just how powerful a character is - and he was due to squash Jericho too.  Backstage, Jericho convinced the booker Eric Bischoff not to change who would win - but to let his character perform some promos in which he would mock Goldberg and flee, weaseling his way out of facing Goldberg directly for a few weeks.  The idea was to wind up the audience, to make it more satisfying for them when Goldberg did eventually get his hands on him.  The idea paid off and Bischoff and Goldberg both appreciated it afterwards - because Jericho was thinking about what would generate heat for the story, rather than what would make him look good.

LARPs rarely if ever ask players to accept that their characters are going to lose outright, so to my mind, we should actually have less temptation to ignore the responsibilities of shared storytelling than wrestlers do.  Nonetheless, we still occasionally see some players that want to hog the plot and shut down others' roles.

Perhaps this is a useful analogy: in wrestling, fan reaction is "heat"; for Larpers, "heat" is player interest.  Imagine that a player is blocking others' enjoyment of the game (and perhaps - as Elle mentioned - using "My character wouldn't do that" as an excuse for not involving other characters).  That player is taking heat out of the game.

Before I stop drawing this parallel, I should mention one practice in wrestling that I would strongly recommend in LARP chronicles - the skill of "putting someone else over".  Some experienced wrestlers - once they have become high-profile - use their prestige to benefit others.  They ask to be given story lines with talented but less-experienced wrestlers that need a push to help them be noticed.  This is pro-active limelight sharing.

Perhaps the best example from wrestling is the Undertaker - a wrestler who rarely loses, not because he's selfish but because his character is intended to be a very powerful monster.  The man who plays him - Mark Calloway - has a lot of years of experience and input into his story lines behind the scenes.  What the Undertaker has occasionally done with his reputation is use it to draw the spotlight to a relatively new wrestler by losing or having a closely-fought match with him.  When Undertaker lost to Brock Lesnar at Wrestlemania, it was the first time that anyone had ever beaten 'Taker at that event, and he had been appearing at Wrestlemania for over twenty years.  By conceding this epic winning streak to Lesnar, Calloway was actually endorsing his opponent in a huge way.

In LARP, character patronage is even easier; it does not have to entail losing a fight with another character.  No matter the form, it can be massively helpful.  I spent a long time in the old Cam UK vampire game playing a relatively low-powered Ventrue, and it was hard to get involved in plot at times, because many characters in that clan were insular, only interested in empire-building for themselves.  As a result, I have a very clear memory of the London game where I first met Tim Edwards, because he was playing a powerful character that actually delegated work and was interested in sponsoring less powerful characters - getting others involved.  Those kinds of interactions can make a player's game for him or her, and should never be underestimated.

I guess the above is a very long-winded way of saying this: "The principles of shared storytelling are really important to live-action stories, and if you don't believe the Larpers that say this, then wrestling can provide all the proof you need."

See you all around, hopefully sooner rather than later.

Monday, 15 December 2014

The Suikoden Model

The prospects for my two-part LARP idea are looking promising; I have received some enthusiastic reactions from potential players and also an offer from someone to act as co-storyteller.  For now, I will keep the volunteer's name a secret... but I'm quite excited about the game and how it may work.

At the same time, I want to do more pen 'n' paper role-playing in 2015.  I've mentioned before that I miss tabletop games, especially running one of my own.  The biggest hurdle seems to be people's availability.  My friends have such busy lives at the moment that signing up to a campaign of tabletop games is just too heavy a commitment, especially when any campaign that I come up with would be competing for a regular time slot with all the other ideas for campaigns, LARPs and regular social engagements that my friends have.

However, Dom's one-shot Cthulhu game has given me an idea.  He ran a single scenario three times for different groups, and he was able to do this because he had a large base of interested players, but each with limited availability.  Dom explained that he usually runs Call of Cthulhu as a campaign, but with players unable to commit to a regular campaign, he developed a one-shot adventure that lasted for about eight hours, and played with three groups of five.

We have a large pool of players in the local area, but all with a lot of commitments.  I don't propose to have a single scenario that I run multiple times, but I have a game - Leverage, which I deeply want to run - that is designed for episodic play.  Each game is supposed to be a stand-alone job lasting for a few hours of play.

What if I also have a pool of players, and each one has a character.  When I come up with a game, it is designed to stand alone, for any five of the players in that pool depending on their availability.  I can then design other one-shot games that are all part of the same campaign, but completely different groups of players could come together on each occasion to tackle the scenario.

This allows the game to cater for players' availability.  Some overlap could exist between the different player groups, because some players would be more available for games than others.  In concept, that would be fine, and could even create some continuity between episodes, even though no player would be required to attend every installment or even more than one installment.  Another advantage of this approach is that I would not have to run the same game twice.

I think I should refer to this idea as the "Suikoden" model of forming a player base for a pen 'n' paper game.  It reminds me of the Suikoden computer RPGs; the player in those games takes the role of an army's leader, and his castle can have over one hundred named characters in it.  However, for the "adventuring-party" sections of the game, the player travels around with a party of up to six of those characters.  What Suikoden provides is the ability to swap out members of the party and field a team that could be different every time.

This could easily gel with the concept of an episodic game about neo-pulp outlaw heroes.  Imagine a network of numerous vigilantees, including thieves, masterminds, con artists, hackers and fighters, and - every so often - a call for help goes out, and a short-term Crew is assembled to deal with the problem from the available members of the network.  I think that the Suikoden model may be the best option that I have for running some tabletop role-playing in 2015 that fits into other people's social calendars, and also lets me role-play with a greater variety of people.

Tuesday, 9 December 2014

Fear of the Unknown

On Saturday, I participated in the third run of Dom Camus' Call of Cthulhu one-shot game.  This is, I think, the only "tabletop" game* that I have played all year, and my biggest regret of 2014 will probably be that I didn't get to role-play nearly as much as I would have liked.

The game was truly excellent and a lot of fun, and had an interesting pre-amble.  I'm used to the gamesmaster explaining the background and setting of the story at the start of the game, but Dom gave a quick briefing about Call of Cthulhu's literary history.  What I had not realised previously was that so much of the material that I recognise from the role-playing game and Arkham Horror comes not from HP Lovecraft's books, but from the work that Sandy Petersen did to fill in the gaps.  I can understand why this was necessary for a role-playing game; gamers need insight into the material if they are going to create their own stories in the Mythos.  However, this got me thinking about whether filling in the gaps meant sacrificing part of what makes Lovecraftian horror so effective - and whether the rules of role-playing games might have this effect on other types of horror.

Part of the scariness of Lovecraft's works comes from gods and monsters that are incomprehensibly alien.  They not only play on fears of monsters and the existential terror of an uncaring universe, but also on fear of the unknown - more than that, the unknowable.  Part of the artistry of Lovecraft's creatures is that they remain mysterious even after they have been witnessed directly and investigated closely.  However, when a game inevitably must give numbers and rules to those creatures, it seems to take some of the scariness out of them.

Only some of it, of course.  Lovecraft's monsters certainly have the advantage that they are terrifying on multiple levels; they're still vast, powerful and hostile, and they inhabit a merciless cosmos in which humanity's insignificance is utterly apparent.

For a more solid example of role-playing rules detracting from horror, I would probably refer to White Wolf's vampire games - Masquerade or Requiem.  The more they codified vampires, the less scary they became.  I'm not surprised that - after 1st edition - Masquerade progressed from a game about personal horror to being about the politics of super-powered immortals.  Having rigid definitions about who can do what is useful for creating divisions, but useless for fostering a fear of the unknown.  Vampire books invite participants to know the source material - to read about what the various clans can do and what varying capabilities vampires have.  As a result, the setting doesn't deliver shocks to the players, even if it should to the characters.  To achieve that effect, a storyteller would probably need to cast a lot of source material to the wind.

The unknown seems to me to be a vital tool for cultivating a sense of immersive horror for players - so that they are actually daunted and not just affecting fear for their characters.  The most success that I have had trying to make a game scary was a session of Doctor Who: Adventures in Time and Space - an episode I called "Dead Memories".  I think that it worked because the antagonist was not a familiar monster or alien from the Doctor Who television series; I came up with an alien that fed on nostalgia and induced hallucinations to trigger memories.  The players had no frame of reference for what they were facing, and I think that this made them respond with more authentic trepidation.

Threats for which we have no frame of reference seem to work well as sources of horror in other media as well.  I think that one of the most effectively scary aspects of Silent Hill was its lack of familiarity.  It provided no clear details about what was happening; players could only really figure things out by experiencing them.  Similarly, I found that Time was a very eerie antagonist in Sapphire & Steel, due to ambiguity about its capabilities.  It certainly helped to give a science fiction show the feel of ghost stories.

One thought that occurs to me is that some heroes in science fiction and fantasy have ambiguous abilities.  The Doctor is a good example, but pulp heroes sometimes fit the bill too.  They are often able to pull off incredible feats, but the audience is not expected to think too closely about how they managed those feats.  Characters that have great power but loosely-defined limitations can be fun or scary, I suppose, depending on whether they are on your side or not.  Perhaps the Doctor, for instance, is an eldritch horror because of his ambiguous capabilities - from the perspective of a Dalek or a Cyberman.



*Granted, I spent most of the game sitting on the floor.

Wednesday, 3 December 2014

Streamlining

Over time, the live-action games that I run seem to be getting shorter and shorter.

LA Confidential lasted for five sessions, as intended.  Upwick Manor hadf a three-episode length.  Now I have a plan for a game - The Last Day of Babylon - that is only two sessions long.

Perhaps the end point is that I will start writing one-shots.  Or will I end up with games that are shorter than that, if even possible?

In a way, planning LARPs seems a little like designing a training package for work.  The more practice I get delivering it, the more streamlined the product becomes.

I think that this is the result of developing as a planner for LARPs.  A lot of storytellers in both live-action and tabletop have had games that run down to a close without reaching a proper finale, myself included.  Past experience suggests to me that wrapping up is better than fading away.  Also - since friends and acquaintances have increasingly busy lives - a game with a fixed finale seems a far less daunting commitment than one with no clear end-point.

Thursday, 27 November 2014

Bottle Episodes

I find that bottle episodes or films are very useful sources of inspiration for running live-action games.  Almost all LARP organisers have to think about the limits to the amount of space that they have, and so bottle stories can teach us a lot about getting entertainment value out of a confined environment.

Sure, a storyteller could ask his players to imagine new locations, but the more that players have to pretend that their characters are in different places without leaving a room, the more a LARP defeats the point of being live-action.

In television, a bottle episode can be described as "the sad little stepchild whose allowance is docked in order to buy big brother a new pair of sneaks". The above quotation is from Scott Brazil, an executive producer on The Shield, pointing out that the practical purpose of a bottle episode is change how costs are distributed during a series - to save some budget for use in finale episodes or cliffhangers.  Most LARPs, on the other hand, have nothing even close to the production capabilities of television, and so - especially if you are planning a small game for a group of friends - researching bottle concepts is a great way to find ideas for reasonable, achievable but also fun stories that would work for a LARP.

I can think of a few good examples:

John Carpenter seems to have a good grasp of bottle concepts in his films; The Thing and Assault on Precinct 13 are both solid examples.  On that note, Ice - the X-Files' season 1 tribute to The Thing - is also an excellent bottle episode - perhaps one of the best in the recent history of television.

One episode of Community called Remedial Chaos Theory is also an interesting example.  It takes place entirely in one room, but shows the stories of seven different timelines originating from a single point - consequences that depended on which member of the study group left the room to collect the pizzas.

Being stuck together on a spaceship is a common way to create a bottle concept; it is frequently blended with horror (e.g. Alien, Event Horizon), but not exclusively so.  The Firefly episodes Our Mrs Reynolds and Objects in Space takes place almost entirely on board the Serenity.

The best bottle episodes for LARPs are usually ones that make full use of an ensemble cast, since they often help storytellers to figure out how to treat multiple players as protagonists in their own right.

I write all these thoughts down, because a bottle film that Shawn recently showed to me has given me an idea for my next LARP - something that we could perhaps do after Paul's angel game.  I'll say more about the idea in a separate post, or in a message to the Egham LARP group, but I'll also be looking for a co-storyteller if I can get interested players.  I tend to get very excited for an idea once I have figured out how it can work in the limited space of the Englefield Green social hall, without asking players to imagine much that is not actually in the rooms.

Tuesday, 11 November 2014

When all roads lead to sexism

I created this blog with the intention of using it to write about my nerdy hobbies instead of my social or political views.  Recently however, I have not been able to turn my mind to my gaming interests without also reading and thinking about the topic of feminism.

Gamergate obviously has some responsibility for this.  In recent months, media coverage has brought to the fore the abuse that some male gamers have heaped on women simply for speaking their minds.  From friends whose writing I follow, like Steve and Pam, to online celebrities like Wil Wheaton and Felicia Day, numerous people of interest have been providing social commentary on misogynist trolls.

However, Gamergate has not been the only source; my other hobbies have been intersecting with the issue of gender discrimination.  Most recently, role-playing has provided me with food for thought on feminism and gender.  What started as research for gaming purposes led to some very educational reading on topical issues.

I'm very keen on Leverage - both as a television series and as a role-playing game.  Part of the appeal is that Leverage is basically neo-pulp; it is about people with extraordinary skills taking on bad guys and making it look fun.  Yet the other part of Leverage's appeal is its basis in reality.  The writers for both the television series and the game books did a lot of research on real abuses of power; behind every fantasy about a group of outlaw heroes bringing a villain to justice is a true story - sadly, it is usually a story about someone rich and powerful getting away with something horrible.

I thought that - if I want to play the game one day - I should conduct some research too.  So I started to look into real abuses of power.  I can't remember how my research started, but I soon found myself reading about harassment of abortion providers and Crisis Pregnancy Centres.  My research went from a relatively-idle curiosity for gaming purposes to more serious interest in short order.


Part of my research included watching the documentary After Tiller, which is about the four doctors that are able to conduct late-term abortions in the United States; a pro-life supporter murdered the fifth.  It certainly shed a lot of light on the people that seek abortions at a late stage.  One example in the film was a rape victim, who had waited a long time to seek an abortion because she had been in denial about the pregnancy.  Her denial was entirely understandable, considering what a terrible thing a rape-induced pregnancy must be to acknowledge, especially while likely traumatised.

Inside the clinics were doctors that cared considerably for their patients, while outside pro-life demonstrators were praying and picketing the facilities.  I can't think of any more powerful way to challenge pro-life attitudes than the footage, which showed a priest telling his congregation that "pure evil" was going on inside a clinic, while inside a doctor listened patiently to a couple explaining that they had wanted to have a baby, and had already built the nursery and got supplies, but then learnt that the baby had a medical condition so severe that it would last just days outside the womb (on life support) before dying.

I gathered information on Crisis Pregnancy Centres (CPCs) from a variety of sources, and they are certainly unsettling.

From reading about social engineering and life hacks, I had already learnt about "round-the-corner" tricks.  Imagine a hustler positioning himself close to a corner shop, and - when the store's owner isn't looking - puts a "deliveries around the corner" sign in front of the shop.  When the postal worker or courier arrives, the hustler meets the delivery man at the side of the property, receives the delivery and subsequently makes off with the goods.  Well, CPCs in the United States are basically a "round-the-corner" trick that religious groups play on pregnant women.

The groups set up "health centres" in close proximity to abortion clinics (to increase the chance that women seeking abortions will enter their centres by mistake), and the centres also have well-designed websites that are intended to make them appear to be medical providers.  However, CPCs do not perform any procedures - the most that they provide is usually an ultrasound.  Their staff are mostly church volunteers, and they use the centres to facilitate meeting women that are seeking abortion.  The purpose of any CPC is to persuade women to bring a baby to term.  By persuade, I mean apply pressure and spread misinformation about the medical implications.  A much more effective explanation than anything I could say can be found here.

What I found most disturbing was the effort and subtlety that goes into making CPCs appear as friendly and professional as possible.  I have visited the actual website of a CPC, and the attention to detail and style is very carefully tailored.

Thanks to the joys of the Internet, I have seen friends and total strangers alike expressing opinions on abortion; some with thought and nuance - others disastrously. 

I tend to get frustrated with the idea that "pro-life" and "pro-choice" are the two defining sides of this issue, as if they are two internally-unified movements.  As far as I can tell, "pro-life" in particular tends to include people with a range of different opinions, some of them contradicting others.

Some pro-life commentators just seem to have the notion that ready access to abortion leads to women using it casually, as if it were a form of retroactive contraception. They may not be able to point to any woman who takes a casual view of such an invasive procedure, but they tend to take issue with the numbers of elective procedures.  As presumptuous as such an opinion may be, at least it implies that the commentator accepts that circumstances - especially medical ones - can make abortion necessary in some cases.  Such pro-lifers also tend to be in favour of contraception, believing that if people took proper precautions then elective procedures would not be occurring for socio-economic reasons.

Such views may be naive, but they do not cause me to fume inwardly - that reaction tends to be reserved for the pro-life activists that are anti-abortion and anti-contraception, and consider that the only safeguard against complications from sex should be abstinence and saving it for marriage.  The moment anyone suggests that people should only be having sex for the purpose of procreation, I feel my blood pressure rising.  This is only compounded when I note that the advocates of this position are usually the religious right, who have in the past supplied the most intimidating and violent harassers of abortion providers.

My anger stems not from research into religion or feminism, but from personal experience - of something that is easier to write about now that I have some distance from it, both in terms of time and emotion.

Until the age of 34, I was a virgin.  I realise that - as an age to first have a sexual relationship - that's actually older than some of my long-term friends are now.  I was not asexual, eschewing sex or maintaining a religious vow.  In fact, if I was to lie and claim that I had been consciously avoiding sex, it would undermine the point that I have in mind.  I wasn't averse to sex, I just did not have sexual relations.

What I can say is that - when you're a man, being a virgin is easy; being perceived as a virgin is hard.  I've seen plenty of fiction that raises the idea that guys need to get laid, but the idea is itself entirely fictional.  It doesn't "straighten you out" or "make a man of you".  If a man goes without it, it does not make him desperate, or scared of women.  In my history of mental health issues, lack of sex was not a contributor and was not conflated with loneliness.

Although not having a sexual relationship was not a cause for concern, I was acutely aware of society's expectations and presumptions about men that don't have sex.  The reason I raise the issue is because men are expected to be having sex long before society puts any pressure on them to be fathers.  Hence my ire towards the religious right on the topic of abortion, because abstinence is simply not a safety net, in the face of all the other pressures put on men to be sexually active.  Even in conservative families and communities that pressure is there, often rendering right-wing groups' reliance on abstinence hypocritical as well as naive.

Initially, the religious right seems to encourage both men and women to abstain, but once an unwanted pregnancy occurs, the role of the man in causing it seems to become almost invisible - and all of the social consequences - particularly censure - fall on the woman.  I can see how church group's behaviour lends a lot of credibility to the notion that pro-life is about controlling women's bodies rather than principle.

One consequence of being a virgin for what my sister once unflatteringly described as a "long, long, long, long time" is that I know that virginity isn't magical (I didn't get to tame any unicorns); it neither emasculates men nor sanctifies women.  This just gives me ample reason to hate this madonna-whore attitude that is threaded through society - that men are expected to be getting laid, and so sexually-available women are needed, but they also have to be demeaned as part of the arrangement, so that the idea of abstinence can keep its respectability for women.  I imagine that feminists would point out to me that this is a defining feature of patriarchy.

I've noticed that I never refer to myself as a feminist - not because I want to distance myself from the term; feminism is not a dirty word.  I can never tell whether I would meet someone else's definition of one, regardless of what I believe. Some people have very inclusive definitions of feminism, while others don't... and the examples that I have seen go back to what I was saying about "pro-life" and "pro-choice" not being internally-unified as movements.

On Thursday, Rosamund Urwin's article in the Evening Standard was about sex-selective abortion (article here).  I found a sad irony in the news that some commentators had told Urwin that she was not a true feminist, just because she had expressed a nuanced view on the topic of abortion.  This mindset of excluding someone for not adhering to a "party line" - for want of a better term - may not be representative of many feminists, but it must be hard to stomach even from a select few.  One of the more abhorrent aspects of Gamergate is that it represents a club of male gamers that clearly wish to exclude women; what could cause more chagrin than to experience marginalisation from some of the people that are supposed to be fighting against such attitudes?

I say "sad irony", because in another context qualifying as a feminist is apparently simple.  As Anita Sarkeesian recently explained to Stephen Colbert, if he believes in standing up for equality between men and women, then he's a feminist.  The behaviour of certain public figures would suggest that some regard acquiring the identity of a feminist to be as easy as putting on a Fawcett Society t-shirt.

David Cameron got a lot of stick in the press for refusing to wear one, after saying that he did not believe in labels.  I'm no fan of Cameron, but I felt that he should not have been criticised for refusing to wear the "This is what a feminist looks like" slogan.  He should be criticised when he actually does something manifestly sexist, like calling a female MP "dear", for example.  However, being skeptical about labels is fair.  As if helping to make this point, a news story came out shortly after the criticisms of Cameron, reporting that Nigel Farage had apparently sent out his wife to buy a Fawcett Society t-shirt for him.  Even if this story was exaggerating or twisting the events, it still reinforced the point that donning a cause's identity and living its values are not the same thing.

One thought that troubles me is the idea that parts of society can be so obsessed with appearances that some people will assume that individuals have values just because they wear certain labels, and vice versa - people will fail to recognise values unless those labels are present.

I recently saw comments on the idea of the UK withdrawing from the European Convention of Human Rights.  One commentator pointed out that ECHR was created after World War II to prevent the values of Nazis from re-emerging; true enough.  He then wrote that we don't need ECHR anymore, because there's no danger of a return to Nazi thinking.  It was just a stunningly misguided comment; evidently the commentator has not heard about Greece's Golden Dawn party, or any of the other far-right groups gaining prominence in Europe.

But is part of the problem that people would have trouble recognising today's fascists, just because they don't helpfully wear skulls and swastikas?  I would hope that such clear visual clues are only needed to identify the bad guys in a Mitchell & Webb sketch....

I think that I should finish this post now.  In truth, it's a mess, but that's what I get for trying to map some of my thoughts on a webpage.  I don't think that I was trying to write about any single issue or particular concern; perhaps I'm just keeping track of the things that influence me, whether by inspiring or disgusting me.

Until next time, yes?  Oh, and hail Hydra.

Tuesday, 21 October 2014

Super Punk and Post-Punk

I used to have little knowledge of the terms "punk" and "post-punk" until Adrian explained them to me.  As I understand their meaning now, "punk" describes a setting where a new development has radically changed society, such as steam technology or cybernetics, and people are still getting accustomed to the change.  "Post-punk" is a setting where people have come to accept the new development, and now it is commonplace and widely-understood.

With superheroes being as prevalent in entertainment media as they are at the moment, I've started to suspect that superhumans have their own punk and post-punk settings.

"Superpunk" - as I shall call it for want of a better term - frequently seems to have the following features:

- People with supernatural powers are only just showing up.
- Most of the general public do not know about these powers, and if they do, people with powers are regarded with suspicion or fear.
- A character in the setting probably had no say in what powers he or she has.
- Many super-powered individuals have limited control over their abilities, and stress can trigger the use of their powers.
- If the story has an ensemble of main characters, they will probably have only one power per person.

These themes seem all too familiar from television shows such as Alphas, the 4400, Heroes and Misfits.  They even apply to the recent Avengers films, since the general public in Marvel's setting are still getting used to the idea of thunder gods, alien beings and heroes in powered armour.

Interestingly, if I want to find something post-superpunk, I would probably have to look at entertainment that is aimed at a much younger audience.  DC's cartoons portray a world that has become accustomed to the existence of powerful superheroes.  Some excellent "post-superpunk" films exist, such as the Incredibles and Sky High, but I cannot deny that they are aimed mostly at children or young adults.

Perhaps this is because of an assumption on the part of film and television producers that older audiences cannot accept fantasy as easily as children can.  A child can accept a character having superpowers after just a few seconds of explanation, whereas adults seem to need to be taken on a whole journey and see how those powers work out in a semi-realistic world before accepting them.  As Steve Dismukes said to me in a recent conversation, DC's Dark Knight films seemed almost apologetic about the fact that they were about a vigilante running around dressed as a giant bat.  Steve may be right that one of the most refreshing things about Guardians of the Galaxy is that it made no apologies; instead it simply presented a fantastic setting full of aliens and space ships - without trying to seem grounded in reality or slathering on exposition.

On the other hand, perhaps superpunk just offers more familiar options that writers can mine for drama.  A world in which having powers could be unacceptable immediately offers more ways to create tension than a world where people have become used to superhumans.

When I look at role-playing instead of television and films, however, the situation seems to be reversed, and the preference seems to be overwhelmingly post-punk.  A lot of games about superheroes (e.g. Champions, Mutants & Masterminds) contain a setting where superheroes and supervillains are well-established.  This may be because these games try to provide a way for role-players to insert their characters into the comic book worlds that they have been reading.  Marvel and DC comics both have their own licensed RPGs, and other games such as Mutants & Masterminds contain a lot of material that references existing comic books - their characters include "Superman by another name" and the like.  I can imagine that another benefit of having a post-superpunk setting is that it allows writers to create heroes, villains, aliens, etc to include in later supplements and thus expand the range of products.

This is not to say that a group of players could not try to tell a "superpunk" story using these games, but they are not really designed to capture that particular narrative flavour, either in their "fluff" or their "crunch".  They provide the chance to trade blows with the Joker or Loki, but their books say a lot less about characters that have to hide powers that they can barely control, and have to fear the social consequences or their controversial abilities.

The closest role-playing game to being "superpunk" that comes to my mind is White Wolf's Hunter: the Reckoning.  It does a lot to capture the themes of a story where characters come into power that they cannot fully control, and they also have to reconcile this development with a world full of people that do not believe in or understand what they are doing.  Hunter: the Reckoning is not quite a perfect example, because the setting's mystical powers only affect other supernatural creatures, but if this caveat and the game's interdependence with the rest of the World of Darkness were removed or ignored, it would be pretty close to what I could call superpunk.